Rock The Vote
October 24th, 2008
In case you haven’t already heard, voting is now open for the 2008 Rails Rumble! Rumble team members already have the ability to vote and just need to log into their accounts to get started. If you weren’t competing but are interested in judging applications, just sign-up for a new account and you’ll be off and running.
How It Works
We’re doing something a little different this year. Voting is not being conducted via the typical free-for-all, anything goes ratings system. For the 2008 event, voters are issued ballots for a limited number of competition apps each day. Each ballot consists of four criteria to rate an app on a five star scale:
- Appearance — The professionalism of the app’s design, aesthetics, usability
- Completeness — How finished does this app feel? Is it missing key features that make it unusable? Is it buggy?
- Innovation — How original and innovative is the app? Is it new, unique, and different or just a rehash of an existing idea?
- Usefulness — Is there an audience for this app? Will it be useful to them? Something they can really use? Or is it superfluous?
This system is designed to evenly distribute ballots for each competition app and only allow each voter’s ballot to count once — though a voter can revise their ratings at any time. Finally, voters will receive new ballots each day, but only to replace the ballots cast.
Why?
It’s understandable that some might be frustrated by this system — especially if they are unable to vote on their favorite apps right away. Remember that the Rumble is not just about winning prizes, but promoting Rails, the Rails community, and all the apps built within the 48 hour event. By going with a ballot system, we’re seeking to level the playing field between apps as much as possible, eliminate ballot stuffing, and ensure that apps are judged based on their individual merits rather than being a simple popularity contest.
In Summary
In summary, getting your vote on is simple:
- Sign-up for an account if you don’t already have one
- Check out each of the apps identified in your freshly minted batch of ballots
- Rate each app on Appearance, Completeness, Innovation, and Usefulness
- Come back tomorrow and use your next batch of ballots
Voting ends at Midnight GMT on 1 Novemember, 2008. Get out, check out those apps, and cast those ballots! Make sure to tell your friends, your family, and especially your fans. Anyone can vote — the more voter diversity we have, the better.
4 Responses to “Rock The Vote”
Sorry, comments are closed for this article.










October 24th, 2008 at 10:13 PM
For next year's rumble, I think you need something to measure how interesting the site is to counteract usefulness. An interesting idea isn't necessarily useful and vice versa.
October 25th, 2008 at 06:55 PM
All comments and criticisms to make this and future events better is always welcome. But doesn't the innovation category cover this? Thanks for your feedback!
October 25th, 2008 at 10:09 PM
I've taken the time to evaluate and rate a couple dozen apps. However, after watching the trends on the leaderboard over the last couple days, I may abstain from further judging. It's quite clear that everyone's scores just continue to drop across the board, which indicates that many judges are voting down almost every app. Could you please consider some statistical analysis to weed out any clearly biased judges?
I'd guess that I'm not the only judge / competitor discouraged by how this is playing out. Although I don't particularly care about the fortunes of my own app (which wasn't complete enough to win, certainly), I've evaluated several excellent apps that are not getting the scores they deserve.
October 29th, 2008 at 09:23 AM
word!
rating with the peergroup works only if nothing is at stake if you vote good for a peer ...
another incredible stupid thing is that you can vote for your own team if you are lucky
btw our project got more votes then visitors ... kinda strange
and most teams only got 3-5 registered users on there portal that is totally closed ... but hundrets of ratings - what did all the people rate? the openid login box?